Snow blower rubber vs steel auger: which one do you need?
You need a steel auger if ice is the main thing you fight, and a rubber or rubber-tipped auger if you mostly clear finished pavement and want parts made to spare the surface.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The labels blur, though: the Snow Joe augers I checked are rubber-tipped steel blades, and several EGO steel augers carry rubber paddles. Read the spec line, not just the headline word.
Best picks by auger type
These picks come from my full buying guides, including my electric snow blower picks; if you want the basics first, start with how a snow blower works.
Best steel-auger single-stage
On Amazon(paid link) 
Illustration EGO Power+ SNT2134
A 21 in steel-auger single-stage that throws up to 45 ft, with two 6.0 Ah batteries included.
Check price on Amazon(paid link)
Best rubber-tipped pick
On Amazon(paid link) 
Illustration Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB22
Four rubber-tipped steel blades clear a 22 in by 13 in path; two 8.0 Ah batteries are included.
Check price on Amazon(paid link)
Best for heavy snow and ice
On Amazon(paid link) 
Illustration EGO Power+ SNT2405
A 24 in self-propelled two-stage with a steel auger, a 20 in intake height and two 7.5 Ah batteries; EGO says that auger breaks up heavy snow and ice.
Check price on Amazon(paid link)
Key takeaways
- Rubber and steel overlap more than the names suggest. A rubber-tipped auger can be steel underneath, and a steel auger can carry rubber paddles.
- Steel is the material tied to ice. It's the auger type credited with cracking ice and icy snow, on two-stage and single-stage machines alike.
- Gravel is a caution zone for both types. Consumer Reports calls single-stage machines a poor fit for it, and crossing it calls for adjusting the housing, scraper bar or skid shoes first.
- Rubber paddles are wear parts. Asphalt and concrete grind them down, and worn ones can leave snow behind.
- The plow pile splits the sources. Every single-stage model in Consumer Reports' plow-pile test struggled, yet EGO says its steel-auger SNT2124 cuts through those banks.
In this guide
- What a rubber auger and a steel auger are
- Which design touches the pavement and pulls the machine
- Wet snow, ice and the plow pile
- Gravel, pavers, decks and stamped concrete
- Wear, paddles and replacement parts
- Which auger the models on this site have
- Which auger fits your driveway
- How I researched this
- FAQ
- Sources
What a rubber auger and a steel auger are
A rubber auger moves snow with rubber paddles or rubber-tipped blades, while a steel auger is a metal auger built to break up snow and ice as it moves them.
Single-stage machines use both
Simplicity and SlashGear describe the single-stage auger as rubber. That isn't the whole picture. The Toro Power Clear e21 is a single-stage with an all-steel Power Edge auger, and the EGO SNT2134 is a single-stage with a steel auger.
Some sit in between. The Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB22 uses 4 rubber-tipped steel blades, and the Cub Cadet single-stage auger is high-impact rubber reinforced with steel. Even a steel auger can carry rubber: the EGO SNT2110 and SNT2130 have rubber paddles on their steel augers.
Two-stage machines
Troy-Bilt and Cub Cadet both build their two-stage augers from steel: serrated at Troy-Bilt, heavy-duty at Cub Cadet. For the other differences, see how single-stage and two-stage machines differ.
Which design touches the pavement and pulls the machine
On a single-stage blower, the auger itself runs close to the ground, whether it's rubber or steel. The Cub Cadet's rubber-and-steel auger clears down to the pavement, and the Toro e21's all-steel auger sweeps down to it too.
Rubber augers can help pull the machine
A rubber auger that grips the pavement also helps move the blower forward. The Cub Cadet single-stage is auger-driven, and the EGO SNT2120AP uses the traction of its rubber augers to help it move forward.
On the SNT2120AP, that traction fades with wear: worn rubber paddles, worn rubber augers and a worn scraper bar are listed causes of snow left behind and lost auger traction.
Two-stage machines have their own drive
The SNT2405 two-stage works differently: independent brushless motors run its self-propel drive and its auger, with variable-speed self-propel in forward and reverse.
Wet snow, ice and the plow pile
Steel is the material the sources connect to ice; on heavy, wet snow and the plow pile, they disagree.
Ice
Troy-Bilt's serrated two-stage augers break up snow and ice before feeding the impeller. If ice is your problem, that's the case for steel. Popular Mechanics also credits the steel auger on EGO's 21-inch single-stage with breaking up icy snow.
Wet snow
Toro and Family Handyman say a single-stage with scooping paddles or a rubber-type auger can handle wet snow. Steel is less settled. EGO says the SNT2134 can clear even the heaviest, wettest snow, while Popular Mechanics lists heavy, wet snow as a possible difficulty for EGO's 21-inch single-stage.
The plow pile
Here the sources split. In Consumer Reports' plow-pile test, all the single-stage models and some compact two-stage machines struggled. Two makers pitch augers built for it. Simplicity says its serrated SnowShredder auger lets a single-stage handle that compacted pile, and EGO says the 6-inch steel auger on its SNT2124 cuts through the snowbanks plows leave.
No source I found tested my two-stage pick, the SNT2405, on a plow pile, so I can't promise it clears one.
Gravel, pavers, decks and stamped concrete
Gravel calls for care with both auger types; on pavers and stamped concrete, check the skid shoes too.
Gravel
Consumer Reports calls a single-stage blower a poor choice for gravel, because its auger runs close to the ground and can pick up stones. On the Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB18 and the Greenworks 60V 22-inch, you raise or adjust the housing height for gravel; on the Westinghouse WSnow22, you raise the scraper bar.
EGO's own documents disagree: the SNT2134 and SNT2124 pages say adjustable skid shoes improve performance on gravel, while the SNT2130 manual says not to use the blower on a graveled surface. The two-stage gets a caution too. On the SNT2405, extra caution is advised on uneven surfaces such as gravel, because the scraper bar can catch on large cracks or other debris. For more, see snow blowers for gravel driveways.
Pavers, decks and stamped concrete
Cub Cadet says its single-stage's rubber-coated paddles won't damage stamped concrete, and Bob Vila says a Greenworks single-stage's rubber blades don't damage pavement. The Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB22's scraper bar helps it clear close to pavement without damaging decks, driveways or pavement.
Skid shoes need watching here: the Concrete Masonry and Hardscape Association says they wear and need adjusting, that worn metal shoes can embed rust-staining filings in pavers, and that synthetic blade edges are worth considering where appearance matters.
Wear, paddles and replacement parts
Rubber paddles wear down on asphalt and concrete, and replacing them is routine upkeep. Buy parts by model number: EGO sells the only replacement paddle approved for the SNT2110 and a rubber paddle set approved only for the auger-propelled SNT2120AP.
Which auger the models on this site have
Both EGO picks have steel augers, and the Snow Joe uses rubber-tipped steel blades.
The EGO Power+ SNT2134 is a 21 in single-stage with a steel auger. Its path is an inch narrower than the Snow Joe's, but it throws snow up to 45 ft against the Snow Joe's 25 ft.
The Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB22 pairs its rubber-tipped auger with a 1600 W brushless motor. At 45.2 lb with batteries installed, it's the one pick here with a listed weight.
The EGO Power+ SNT2405 is the widest pick at 24 in, a self-propelled two-stage with a metal auger and a throw of up to 50 ft.
Which auger fits your driveway
For a paved driveway, I'd start with a rubber-tipped single-stage like the Snow Joe 24V-X2-SB22. For ice, go steel: the SNT2134 as a single-stage, or the SNT2405 as a self-propelled two-stage. On gravel, plan on adjusting the machine first; on pavers, favor rubber and watch the skid shoes.
How I researched this
I read 36 sources for this page: snow blower makers' pages, manuals and guides, Consumer Reports and Bob Vila. The picks come from my buying guides, where I compared 23 products in detail.
FAQ
What does "rubber-tipped" mean on a snow blower auger?
It means steel blades with rubber tips. Snow Joe uses 4 of them on its SJ627E, 24V-X2-SB18 and 24V-X2-SB22, and the Westinghouse WSnow22 rotor is built the same way.
How can I tell which auger an EGO model has?
Go by the full model number. The SNT2134, SNT2124, SNT2122 and SNT2120 are steel-auger single-stage models, and the SNT2112 is listed as the 21-inch Peak Power blower with steel auger. The auger-propelled SNT2120AP is different: it has rubber augers and rubber paddles.
When should rubber paddles be replaced?
Replace them once they're worn, cracked, frayed or damaged, the rule EGO sets for the SNT2130. To make changes less frequent, Toro sells an extended-life paddle kit for its Power Clear and CCR blowers.
What batteries come with the three picks?
The SNT2134 kit has two 6.0 Ah batteries, the SNT2405 kit two 7.5 Ah batteries and the Snow Joe kit two 24 V 8.0 Ah batteries, each with a dual-port charger. All EGO batteries work with all EGO tools, so the two EGO picks can share packs.
What run time do the makers give for these picks?
None of the three pages gives a run time in minutes. EGO rates the SNT2134 for up to a 14-car driveway and the SNT2405 for up to an 18-car driveway, each with 8 in of snow on a single charge with the recommended batteries.
What does a snow blower warranty say about the auger?
It varies by maker. Honda's manual warranty excludes impact and abrasive damage to auger and paddle assemblies. Both EGO picks carry a 5-year tool warranty, and the Snow Joe carries 2 years.
Sources
More guides
- Best electric snow blowerFive corded and battery models compared on clearing width, throw distance, run time, weight and warranty.
- Best snow blower for womenFive picks ranked by weight, how they start and whether they drive themselves.
- Single-stage vs two-stage snow blowerHow each type moves snow, and which one fits your snow depth and driveway surface.
- Gas vs electric snow blowerMaintenance, starting, run time, power for heavy snow and noise, side by side.
- Snow Joe snow blower reviewThree Snow Joe models, one corded and two battery, compared on maker specs.
- Greenworks snow blower reviewTwo Greenworks 60V single-stage models compared on maker specs, with what each page leaves out.
- Snow blowers for heavy snowFive battery picks compared on stages, intake height, throw distance and battery kit.
- Snow blower for a gravel drivewayFour two-stage battery picks and one single-stage, with what each maker says about gravel.
- Electric snow shovel vs snow blowerClearing width and depth, throw distance, weight, snow type and surface, with two shovel picks and two blower picks.
- Compact electric snow blowersFour small models, 16 to 20 inches wide, compared on clearing width, weight, storage and corded or battery power.
- Snow blower vs snow throwerWhether the two names mean the same machine, what the makers call their own models, and how single-stage and two-stage machines move snow.
- Corded vs cordless snow blowerRun time, extension cords and outlets, weight, cold weather and warranty, with two corded and two cordless picks.
- EGO vs Greenworks snow blowerBattery platforms, warranty, clearing width and throw, two-stage options, and weight and storage, with two picks from each brand.
- EGO SNT2405 vs SNT2416Two 24-inch EGO kits compared on batteries, clearing width, throw, controls and warranty.
- Snow blower vs shovelEffort and strain on the body, snow depth, driveway size, upkeep and noise, with four snow blower picks.
- What size snow blower do I needClearing width by driveway size, snow depth by machine type, corded or cordless, and the extension cord gauges the makers' manuals give.
- Do electric snow blowers workHow much snow they handle, wet snow, plow piles, ice and gravel, battery run time in the cold, and when gas is the better call.
- How does a snow blower work?How the auger, impeller and chute move snow, what powers them, the safety controls, clearing a clog and gravel.
- Snow blower vs plowSnow blower or plow for a driveway: where the snow goes, snow depth, gravel, the end-of-driveway plow pile and plow types.
- Snow blower vs leaf blowerWhich snow a leaf blower can clear, where it falls short, and when a snow blower is the right tool.
- Best cordless snow blowersFive battery models compared on the batteries in the kit, single or two-stage, clearing width, throw distance and warranty.
- EGO snow blower reviewFive EGO Power+ models, single and two-stage, compared on maker specs and manuals.
- EGO SNT2134 reviewWhat the 21-inch EGO kit gets you: throw, batteries, cold weather, gravel, weight and warranty.
- EGO SNT2405 reviewThe 24-inch self-propelled EGO kit: controls, drive, weight, batteries, gravel and what testers found.
- Westinghouse snow blower reviewThree Westinghouse models, one 48V cordless and two corded, compared on maker pages and manuals.
- EGO SNT2400 vs SNT2410Two tool-only 24-inch EGO machines compared on chute and steering controls, reverse drive, heated grips, batteries, weight and warranty.
- Snow Joe vs Westinghouse snow blowerCorded and battery models from both brands compared on path size, throw, battery platform, warranty terms and weight.