Snow blower vs plow: which one fits your driveway?

A plow usually fits a long, wide driveway with room to push snow, while a snow blower fits a drive with nowhere to put the snow, or snow that BOSS and Hobby Farms say can be too deep or too wet for a small plow. Your surface and your vehicle matter too, and so does the ridge the street plow leaves at the end of the drive.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Below are the snow blowers I'd pick for those jobs, then the details, one question at a time.

Best snow blowers for the jobs a plow leaves

If you want the full comparison, it's in my electric snow blower picks.

  • Best for plow banks

    EGO Power+ SNT2425On Amazon
    Illustration of a two-stage snow blower
    Illustration

    EGO Power+ SNT2425

    Two-stage and self-propelled, 24 in wide with a 20 in intake and a remote chute joystick.

  • Best for gravel

    EGO Power+ SNT2405On Amazon
    Illustration of a two-stage snow blower
    Illustration

    EGO Power+ SNT2405

    Two-stage with adjustable skid shoes and forward-and-reverse self-propel; its scraper bar can catch on gravel debris.

  • Best for paved driveways

    EGO Power+ SNT2134On Amazon
    Illustration of a battery snow blower
    Illustration

    EGO Power+ SNT2134

    21 in single-stage with up to 45 ft of throw, two 6.0 Ah batteries and a 5-year tool warranty.

Key takeaways

  • Where the snow ends up is the big split. A blade shoves snow to the edge of the drive. A blower sends it off the surface you're clearing.
  • Long driveways lean toward a plow. With space along the sides to push snow, a plow is usually the more efficient tool for a long, wide drive.
  • Deep or wet snow can tip it toward a blower. BOSS says deep snow, and Hobby Farms says wet, heavy snow, can be too much for a small plow.
  • Gravel needs the edge raised. Shoes under a plow blade and a raised housing on a two-stage blower both keep the scraping edge up off the stones.
  • The ridge at the end of the drive is on you. The street plow leaves it there, and the homeowner is the one who clears it.
In this guide
  1. How a plow and a snow blower move snow
  2. Where the snow goes: piles and banks vs throwing it away
  3. Driveway size, snow depth and wet snow
  4. Gravel driveways: plow shoes and skid shoes
  5. The plow pile at the end of the driveway
  6. ATV, UTV, tractor or truck plow, or hiring a service
  7. How I researched this
  8. FAQ
  9. Sources

How a plow and a snow blower move snow

A plow pushes snow with a blade, and a snow blower throws it. The blade moves snow aside to wherever there's room. A blower sends it away from the cleared surface.

Hobby Farms puts the trade-off plainly: a blower's main advantage is that it propels snow away instead of shoving it aside, but it's generally slower than a plow.

A plow rides on a vehicle, such as an ATV, a UTV, a truck or a tractor. On a tractor, you can mount either tool, a front blade or a snow blower attachment. If you want the blower side in more detail, here's how the auger and impeller move snow.

Where the snow goes: piles and banks vs throwing it away

A plow needs somewhere to push the snow, and a snow blower doesn't, because it throws the snow away from the area you're clearing. Small Farm Canada points to tree-lined and fenced driveways as blower jobs, since the machine throws snow far away and keeps snowbanks from building up. With a plow, you're stacking snow along the edges instead.

Banks also grow. As winter goes on, they get harder to push through or around, and one pile can last through several plowings. So if you plow, plan where the pile goes before you start, and leave room for several storms, not just the first one.

Driveway size, snow depth and wet snow

A long driveway favors a plow, while deep or wet snow favors a snow blower over a small plow. Here's how that plays out.

Long, wide driveways

For a long, wide drive with room along the sides, a plow is generally the more efficient way to clear it. That's the plow's home ground.

On a wide drive, start in the middle with either machine. Meyer's plow method then tilts the blade to push snow to both sides, and Troy-Bilt says alternating a blower's throw direction clears the drive in fewer passes.

Deep snow

Deep snow can be too much for a smaller plow to push, and that's where a blower can come out ahead. Think of a storm that buries the drive overnight before work.

Snow blowers have limits too. Troy-Bilt puts single-stage machines at light snow of 3 to 9 inches on paved surfaces. Two-stage machines take the heavier work. Toro puts them at snowfalls of 12 inches or more, big drifts and hard, compacted snow. For deeper storms, my guide to which snow blower handles heavy snow goes further.

Wet snow

Wet, heavy snow is another blower case: Hobby Farms notes that a small plow truck or ATV/UTV plow may struggle with it, where a blower has the advantage. If your storms tend to come in wet, weigh that before you buy a small plow.

Gravel driveways: plow shoes and skid shoes

On gravel, both a plow and a two-stage snow blower need their edge raised off the stones.

Plowing gravel

Plowing gravel moves some of the gravel, into the pile or onto the lawn. Plow shoes attach under the blade and lift it so it rides over the gravel. The packed snow left on top then works as a buffer between blade and stones.

Fisher's numbers: leave about an inch of snow between the blade and the gravel, go slowly, and angle the blade around 40 to 45 degrees to reduce scraping.

Blowing gravel

A two-stage snow blower is the type for gravel, and Toro says single-stage machines shouldn't be used on unpaved surfaces. For gravel, raise the auger housing so the scraper bar clears the stones.

The SNT2405 has adjustable skid shoes. On a gravel drive, take extra care: its scraper bar can catch on large cracks or other debris. Makers describe the shoe adjustment differently: Ariens says lower the shoes to raise the housing, while Troy-Bilt says set them to the highest position.

For more picks, see my list of snow blowers for gravel driveways.

The plow pile at the end of the driveway

The plow pile at the end of the driveway is the homeowner's job to clear.

In Consumer Reports' plow pile test, most two- and three-stage blowers handled it, while some compact two-stage models and all the single-stage models it tested struggled. My pick for this job is the SNT2425, a two-stage, 24 in machine with a 20 in intake height and up to 50 ft of throw.

How to clear the pile

Consumer Reports' method: get to the pile right away before it refreezes, break a crusty pile into chunks with a shovel, work slowly with the machine's nose lowered so the auger digs in, take passes about half the width of the intake, and don't throw the snow back into the street.

You can also clear a pocket about 10 feet long and a car width wide beside the driveway, so the street plow drops its snow there. Consumer Reports and FOX 9 both describe it but place it on opposite sides of the driveway.

ATV, UTV, tractor or truck plow, or hiring a service

BOSS sorts the options by property: an ATV plow for narrow sidewalks and pathways, a UTV for wider driveways and larger properties, a pickup with a plow if you already own a suitable truck, and a contractor if you'd rather not own, maintain, store and operate equipment at all.

On a tractor, the choice is a front blade or a snow blower attachment. A John Deere dealer's guide calls front blades ideal for smaller jobs such as driveways, and saves the snowblower attachment for when plowing snow out of the way isn't enough. The attachment throws the snow a good distance off the drive instead of pushing it.

How I researched this

I read 28 sources for this page: plow makers' guides and an ATV plow manual, snow blower makers' guides, a city public works FAQ, a CPSC safety alert, and Consumer Reports, Bob Vila and farm-magazine articles. The picks come from my buying guides, where I compared 23 products in detail.

FAQ

What is a windrow?

A windrow is the row of snow a street plow leaves at the bottom of a driveway. The Farmington Hills public works FAQ says homeowners clear it, and that plow operators can't avoid it by lifting the plow.

How fast should you drive when plowing a driveway?

No faster than 10 miles per hour on a residential drive, per Meyer, and a Kolpin ATV plow manual sets 5 mph as the limit with the blade installed.

What is the safe way to clear a clogged snow blower chute?

CPSC advises stopping the engine and clearing it with a stick, because snow thrower injuries most often happen when people clear the auger or chute with their hands.

How far do the EGO picks throw snow?

Up to 50 ft for the SNT2425 and the SNT2405, and up to 45 ft for the SNT2134. The SNT2425 aims its chute with a remote joystick, while the SNT2134 uses handle-mounted levers.

What batteries come with the EGO picks?

The SNT2425 and SNT2405 kits come with two 7.5 Ah batteries, and the SNT2134 kit with two 6.0 Ah batteries, each with a dual-port charger. All three use Peak Power, which combines two EGO 56 V batteries. The SNT2420, SNT2400 and SNT2130 are sold as the blower only, with no battery or charger.

What warranty do the EGO picks carry?

A 5-year tool warranty and a 3-year battery warranty, on the SNT2425, the SNT2405 and the SNT2134 alike.

Sources

More guides